Hello dear
Welcome To Original Italian Pizza - Pine Grove
Original Italian Pizza - Pine Grove, located at 174 S Tulpehocken St, is a charming eatery that captures the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. Nestled in a repurposed church, it offers a cozy dining atmosphere, perfect for enjoying their delectable offerings. Their menu boasts a variety of pizzas, including the thin-crust white pizzas and rich calzones, all crafted with high-quality ingredients that delight the palate. Diners have praised the friendly service and generous portion sizes, making it a must-visit for both locals and travelers. Whether you're craving pizza or a juicy cheeseburger, you’ll leave with a satisfied appetite and a smile.
About
Original Italian Pizza - Pine Grove
Welcome to Original Italian Pizza - Pine Grove, a hidden gem nestled in the charming town of Pine Grove, PA. Located in a converted church at 174 S Tulpehocken St, this authentic Italian pizzeria stands out in a sea of dining options with its dedication to quality and tradition.
First stepping inside, you’re greeted by an inviting atmosphere that melds the rustic charm of its historical setting with the delightful aroma of freshly baked pizza. The menu is a testament to the art of pizza-making, offering both Sicilian-style and specialty pizzas that cater to all tastes. Choose from classics like the Plain Cheese Pizza or indulge in the hearty Meat Lovers Pizza, packed with sausage, pepperoni, and ham.
What truly sets Original Italian Pizza apart are the customer experiences shared in recent reviews. Michael Girardo, a visitor from Georgia, raved about the thin and crispy crust, reminiscent of the best pizza from his hometown. He highlighted how it has been a long time since he enjoyed a pie with a "crunchy crust" and is looking forward to returning on future trips.
The restaurant also offers an array of unique dishes such as the Taco Pizza and Stuffed Pizza, which showcases creative takes on traditional favorites. Likewise, the Strombolis, like the Chicken Parmesan Stromboli, promise a savory delight with every bite. Customers like Cory Miller have noted the quality ingredients that contribute to genuine Italian flavors, while also enjoying the spacious dining area and outdoor pavilion perfect for sunny days.
Reviews from patrons such as Amber Thomas keep highlighting the joy of discovering delightful items like ham and cheese puffs, further confirming that every visit can yield new culinary surprises. Brittany echoed a similar enthusiasm, noting the delightful environment and the quality of the pizza, and highly recommending a visit to this distinct eatery.
Whether you're a local or just passing through, Original Italian Pizza - Pine Grove is a must-visit. With its commitment to quality and customer satisfaction, it's no wonder that this establishment has garnered such a positive reputation. So grab a slice and experience the authentic flavors of Italy right in Pine Grove!
For inquiries, you can reach them at +1 570-345-5432.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Absolutely love their food! My husband and I found it and tried for the first time the food was so good and we saw these ham and cheese puffs in the window we had to come back and get those another day. And yes they were just as delicious!! Would definitely recommend you try it ”
“ Really great pizza, so far we haven't tried anything else but I would recommend checking this place out. The building is in an old church, and they have a nice area to eat in or you can eat outside. ”
“ We are visiting the area for a weekend of off-roading and wanted Pizza. We live in GA (originally from the Philly metro area) and don't have good pizza where we live. When we found Original Italian Pizza, we were cautiously optimistic. We bought a couple of slices each and were pleasantly surprised. The crust was thin and crispy. It's been a long time since I've had a pizza with a crunchy crust. It was so enjoyable. I wish we had found Original Italian Pizza when we came up last year. It will definitely be at least one meal when we come up in the future. ”
“ The food was great! Very large portions! The people who were working there were sooo very kind and helpful! One of he best OIP restaurants we have been to. ”
“ Definitely an authentic Italian pizza shop with quality ingredients. Tried their pizza and bacon cheeseburger with fries. Cheeseburger came with no vegetables (perhaps I needed to request them), bun was homemade as other reviewers suggested which I didn’t care for but it was fresh. Fries were crinkle cut and a bit too well done (dark brown) so you might as to have them lightly done. That said, pizza was amazing. I ordered a pan pizza that was pleasantly thick and had a crunchy crust done to perfection. Wide variety of drinks and even juices to choose from. Ample room inside and a roomy covered outdoor pavilion to use on a nice day. Glad I stopped by on my travels to visit this destination. ”
“ Great Pizza! But if you really want something good try their Cheeseburger Sub! OMG! With their homemade bread, this Sub is off the hook! The dining room is spacious & very clean. Definitely check out OIP in Pine Grove if you're in the area. ”
“ OMG!!! Ordered 2 medium size regular calzones and boy were we surprised at how huge they were!!! And the flavor?! It's just amazing! I've never had pizza this good in my life! My husband and I really enjoyed it and loved that we were able to get it delivered to our semi truck! Will definitely order again!!!!!!! ”
“ I ordered delivery while passing through town. The staff were so polite, delivery was super fast, and the food was absolutely amazing. Would highly recommend! ”